• South Jersey Radiology: THE leader in diagnostic imaging
  • Book Appointment
  • Express Check In
  • Locations
  • Walk-in X-rays
Call 1.888.909.SJRA (7572) today!
HealthFlex
×
  • About SJRA
    • About Us
    • Careers
    • Contact Us
    • Corporate Headquarters
    • DICOE
    • Giving Back
    • Physicians
    • Technologies
  • Patients & Visitors
    • Billing Questions
    • Book an Appointment
    • Express Check In
    • Forms
    • Insurance
      • Billing Questions
      • Glossary of Terms
      • Insurance Participation List
      • Pay Online
    • Locations
    • Men’s Imaging
      • Men’s Imaging Overview
      • Cardiac MRI
      • CT Angiography
      • CT Arthrography (Any Joint)
      • CT Scan / Cat Scan
      • Echocardiogram (2D)
      • MR Angiography
      • MR Arthrogram
      • MR Venography
      • MRI
      • Nuclear Medicine
      • Prostate MRI
      • Ultrasound Vascular Doppler
      • Virtual Colonoscopy
      • X-Rays and Barium Studies
    • Patient Portal
    • Patient Rights
    • SJRA Notice of Privacy Practices
    • Test Prep/Forms
    • Pay Your Bill
    • Pediatrics
      • Pediatric Imaging Overview
      • CT Angiography
      • CT Arthrography
      • CT Scan / Cat Scan
      • MR Angiography
      • MR Arthrogram
      • MR Venography
      • MRI
      • Nuclear Medicine
      • X-Rays & Barium Studies
    • Physicians
    • Women’s Imaging
      • Women’s Imaging Overview
      • 3D Digital Tomosynthesis
      • Breast Biopsy
      • Breast Imaging
      • Dexa Scan
      • Digital Mammography
      • Echocardiogram (2D)
      • Ultrasound
      • Ultrasound Echo Sonogram
      • Ultrasound Fetal
      • Ultrasound Transvaginal
      • Ultrasound Vascular Doppler
  • Services
    • Services Overview
    • Breast Imaging
      • Breast Imaging Overview
      • 2D Mammography
      • 3D Mammography
    • Cardiac Imaging
      • Cardiac Imaging Overview
      • Cardiac MRI
      • Coronary CTA
      • CT Angiography
      • Echocardiogram (2D)
      • MR Angiography (MRA Any Area)
      • MR Venography (MRV Any Area)
      • Ultrasound Vascular Doppler
    • CT Scan / CAT Scan
      • CT Scan / Cat Scan Overview
      • CT Angiography
      • CT Arthrography
    • Dexa Scan
    • Fluoroscopy
    • Mammography
      • Mammography
      • 3D Digital Tomosynthesis
      • Breast Biopsy
      • Digital Mammography
    • Men’s Imaging
      • Men’s Imaging Overview
      • CT Angiography
      • CT Arthrography
      • CT Scan / Cat Scan
      • Cardiac MRI
      • Dexa Scan
      • Echocardiogram (2D)
      • MR Angiography
      • MR Arthrogram
      • MR Venography
      • MRI
      • Nuclear Medicine
      • PET / CT Scan
      • Prostate MRI
      • Sports Medicine
      • Ultrasound Vascular Doppler
      • Virtual Colonoscopy
      • X-Rays & Barium Studies
    • MRI
      • MR Angiography (MRA Any Area)
      • MR Arthrogram (Any Area)
      • MR Venography (MRV Any Area)
      • MRI
    • Nuclear Medicine
    • Pediatric Imaging
      • Pediatric Imaging Overview
      • CT Angiography
      • CT Arthrography
      • CT Scan / Cat Scan
      • MR Angiography (MRA Any Area)
      • MR Arthrogram (Any Area)
      • MR Venography (MRV Any Area)
      • MRI
      • Nuclear Medicine
      • PET / CT Scan
      • X-Rays & Barium Studies
    • PET / CT Scan
    • Screenings
      • Breast Imaging
      • Cardiac Imaging
      • Lung Screenings
    • Ultrasound
      • Echocardiogram (2D)
      • Ultrasound
      • Ultrasound Echo Sonogram
      • Ultrasound Fetal
      • Ultrasound Transvaginal
      • Ultrasound Vascular Doppler
    • Virtual Colonoscopy
    • Women’s Imaging
      • Women’s Imaging Overview
      • 3D Digital Tomosynthesis
      • Breast Biopsy
      • Breast Imaging
      • Dexa Scan
      • Digital Mammography
      • Echocardiogram (2D)
      • Ultrasound
      • Ultrasound Echo Sonogram
      • Ultrasound Fetal
      • Ultrasound Transvaginal
      • Ultrasound Vascular Doppler
    • X-Rays and Barium Studies
  • Healthcare Professionals
    • CPT Listing 2021
    • CT & MRI: How and When to Use Contrast
    • Education
    • Insurance Participation List
    • Intelerad PACS System
      • Login or Apply for Account
      • Support & Downloads
    • Precertification Request Service
    • Referring Physicians
      • Breast Cancer Screening Recommendations
      • CPT LIsting 2021
      • CT & MRI: How and When to Use Contrast
      • Education
      • Insurance Participation List
      • Intelerad PACS System
        • Login or Apply for Account
        • Support & Downloads
      • Precertification Request Service
      • SJRA Forms
    • SJRA Forms
  • Employers
    • Employer Partner Program
  • Blog
    • Blog
    • Blog Archives
    • News
  • Contact Us

New York Times Article on Mammography Extremely Flawed

February 12, 2014Blog

EXTREMELY FLAWED CANADIAN STUDY ON MAMMOGRAPHY

An Article published in the British Medical Journal questioning the value of screening mammography is one of the most flawed studies ever published.   This misleading analysis was based on the deeply flawed and widely discredited Canadian National Breast Screening Study (CNBSS). The results of this BMJ study, and others resulting from the CNBSS trial, should not be used to create breast cancer screening policy as this would place a great many women at increased risk of dying unnecessarily from breast cancer.

Experts called on to review the CNBSS confirmed that the mammography quality was poor (2). The trial used second hand mammography machines, which were not state of the art at the time of the trial. The images were compromised by “scatter,” which makes the images cloudy and cancers harder to see since they did not employ grids for much of the trial. Grids remove the scatter and make it easier to see cancers. Also, technologists were not taught proper positioning. As such, many women were not properly positioned in the machines, resulting in missed cancers. And the CNBSS radiologists had no specific training in mammographic interpretation. The CNBSS own reference physicist stated that “…in my work as reference physicist to the NBSS, [I] identified many concerns regarding the quality of mammography carried out in some of the NBSS screening centers. That quality [in the NBSS] was far below state of the art, even for that time (early 1980s).”(3)

To be valid, randomized, controlled trials (RCT) must employ a system to ensure that the assignment of women to the screening group or the unscreened control group is random. Nothing can/should be known about participants until they have been assigned to one of these groups. The CNBSS violated these fundamental rules (6). Every woman first had a clinical breast examination by a trained nurse so that they knew which women had breast lumps, many of which were cancers, and which women had large lymph nodes in their armpits many of which indicated advanced cancer. Before assigning the women to be in the group offered screening or the control women, investigators knew who had large incurable cancers. This was a major violation of RCT protocol. It most likely resulted in the statistically significant excess of women with advanced breast cancers assigned to the screening arm compared to those assigned to the control arm (7). This guaranteed more deaths among the screened women than the control women.

The five year survival from breast cancer among women ages 40–49 in Canada in the 1980s was only 75 percent, yet the control women in the CNBSS, who were supposed to reflect the Canadian population at the time, had a greater than 90 percent five year survival (8). This indicates that cancers may have been shifted from the control arm to the screening arm. Coupling the fundamentally corrupted allocation process with the documented poor quality of the mammography should have long ago disqualified the CNBSS as a legitimate trial of modern screening mammography.

Recent Posts

  • SOUTH JERSEY RADIOLOGY HAS MODIFIED OFFICE LOCATIONS AND HOURS
  • SOUTH JERSEY RADIOLOGY UPDATE FOR MARCH 13, 2020
  • “ONE PLUS ONE EQUALS THREE” IN PROSTATE IMAGING
  • IMPORTANT INFORMATION FOR HEAVY SMOKERS AND FORMER SMOKERS
  • An Ounce of Prevention….

Location Guide

Plan your visit to SJRA

More

SJRA Archives

  • 2020
  • 2019
  • 2018
  • 2017
  • 2016
  • 2015
  • 2014
  • 2013
  • 2012
  • 2011
  • 2010
  • 2009
  • 2008
  • 2004

About Us

Our focus is on our patients and their needs. At SJRA, we believe every patient is entitled to the highest level of technology and expertise available. Our dedication to quality patient care can be measured, in part, by continuing to invest in state-of-the-art technology.

1.888.909.7572

https://www.sjra.com

1307 White Horse Rd, Ste A102, Voorhees, NJ 08043

Quick Links

  • Contact Us
  • Book Appointment
  • Express Check In
  • Locations
  • Careers
  • Medical Disclaimer
  • News Room
  • Patient Portal
  • Pay Your Bill
  • Physicians
  • Privacy Policy
  • Blog Archives

The South Jersey Radiology Difference!

American College of Radiology Breast Imaging Center of ExcellenceSince 1938, the South Jersey Radiology (SJRA) staff is comprised of Board Certified Radiologists who have sub-specialty training — that is, specific expertise in neuroradiology, body imaging, bone joint imaging, cardiac imaging, nuclear radiology, and women’s imaging. Our dedicated team hails from acclaimed medical schools such as Harvard, Stanford, Brown, Duke and UMDNJ. No need to travel outside of South Jersey – our radiologists have more than 500 combined years of experience in diagnostic medical imaging right here in your own backyard!

In an era of higher insurance deductibles, higher co-pays, co-insurance policies and self-pay patients, please consider that SJRA provides world-class medical technologies at a fraction of the cost. #insistonSJRA


Diagnostic-Imaging-Center-of-Excellence95
SJRA is the ONLY Diagnostic Imaging Center of Excellence in the region to win this award from the American College of Radiology.
Copyright © 2020 South Jersey Radiology. All Rights Reserved.